The Consensus 2005 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of four major All-American teams. To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Associated Press, the USBWA, The Sporting News and the National Association of Basketball Coaches.

2005 Consensus All-America team

Individual All-America teams

AP Honorable Mention: • Eddie Basden, Charlotte • Brandon Bass, LSU • Turner Battle, Buffalo • Tim Begley, Penn • Mike Bell, Florida Atlantic • Josh Boone, Connecticut • Seamus Boxley, Portland State • Darren Brooks, Southern Illinois • Pat Carroll, St. Joseph's • Taylor Coppenrath, Vermont • Travis Diener, Marquette • David Doubley, Pacific • Jared Dudley, Boston College • Nick Fazekas, Nevada • Channing Frye, Arizona • Francisco García, Louisville • Ryan Gomes, Providence • Danny Granger, New Mexico • Caleb Green, Oral Roberts • Blake Hamilton, Monmouth • Kevin Hamilton, Holy Cross • Chuck Hayes, Kentucky • Chakowby Hicks, Norfolk State • Julius Hodge, NC State • Jarrett Jack, Georgia Tech • Willie Jenkins, Tennessee Tech • Alex Loughton, Old Dominion • John Lucas III, Oklahoma State • Ed McCants, Wisconsin-Milwaukee • Rashad McCants, North Carolina • Juan Mendez, Niagara • Adam Morrison, Gonzaga • Yemi Nicholson, Denver • Pele Paelay, Coastal Carolina • Anthony Roberson, Florida • Lawrence Roberts, Mississippi State • Craig Smith, Boston College • Steven Smith, La Salle • Joe Thompson, Sam Houston State • Obie Trotter, Alabama A&M • Ronny Turiaf, Gonzaga • Eric Williams, Wake Forest • Kennedy Winston, Alabama • Brendan Winters, Davidson

Academic All-Americans

On March 2, 2005, CoSIDA and ESPN The Magazine announced the 2005 Academic All-America team, with Chris Hill headlining the University Division as the men's college basketball Academic All-American of the Year. The following is the 2004–05 ESPN The Magazine Academic All-America Men's Basketball Team (University Division) as selected by CoSIDA: